G20 leaders to meet in India amid a global turn inward

Alex Willemyns for RFA
G20 leaders to meet in India amid a global turn inward Students work on paintings of world leaders at an art school in Mumbai, India, ahead of the G20 summit in New Delhi, Sept. 5, 2023.
[Punit Paranjpe/AFP]

The Group of Twenty leaders’ summit in New Delhi this weekend is meant to be a jubilee of economic cooperation for the industrialized world.

But some 15 years after the G20 declared itself the premier forum of global economic decision-making, few anticipate major announcements this year. This year’s summit is taking place at a time of growing insularity in the world’s two largest economies, China and the United States.

The best hope is for a “nicely-worded – but naturally vague –  statement” pledging to tackle long-standing issues like climate change and cybercrime, said Miguel Chanto, the chief economist for emerging Asia at Pantheon Macroeconomics, an independent research firm.

“I doubt there’ll be anything of substance,” he said, “reflecting the fact national governments mainly are preoccupied with domestic affairs and these types of international fora have, over the years, proven incapable of bringing about real, actionable and enforceable reform.”

Global South leadership

The summit is nonetheless a big deal in host-country India, which has reportedly spent more than U.S. $100 million in preparations for the weekend event. The buildup to the summit has included a nationwide propaganda campaign by the Narendra Modi government about India’s rising place in the world and a renewed push of Hindu nationalism.

Copy of ENG_CHN_G20_09062023.2.jpg
A scrap-iron sculpture of a komodo dragon, the national animal of Indonesia, is displayed at a park in New Delhi, ahead of the G20 India summit. Sept. 5, 2023. [Arun Sankar/AFP]

But Chinese President Xi Jinping, who has traveled only to Russia and South Africa this year, won’t be there. China’s premier, Li Qiang, will attend in his stead amid icy ties with the United States and allies like Japan, which Beijing chided for releasing treated nuclear wastewater.

U.S. President Joe Biden last weekend said he was “disappointed” he would not get to see Xi face-to-face at the meeting, before adding that he was still “going to get to see him,” without any explanation.

Amid a stumbling Chinese economy made worse by last week’s announcement of a record U.S. $6.7 billion loss by real estate giant Country Garden, Xi has enough reasons to stay away from New Delhi, especially while India is burnishing its credentials as an alternative economy to China.

“China’s position at the G20, and these kinds of global forums, is undermined,” said Suisheng Zhao, director of the Center for China-U.S. Cooperation at the University of Denver. “They are competing to be the leader of the Global South, and China now does not have money.”

“Even with the Belt and Road Initiative, everything has been undermined by the economic difficulties,” he said. “China’s so-called ‘China model of economic growth’ and the superiority of China’s model of authoritarian state capitalism is now all in question.”

US protectionism

But Xi will lose little sleep contemplating Biden or any other leader launching a major new economic initiative at New Delhi.

Copy of ENG_CHN_G20_09062023.3.JPG
A construction site of residential buildings by Chinese developer Country Garden is pictured in Tianjin, China, Aug. 18, 2023. [Tingshu Wang/Reuters]

The United States, after all, has also largely turned inward since Donald Trump’s 2016 campaign upended bipartisan agreement on free-trade, with both the U.S. poltical parties now actively shunning it. 

Jake Sullivan, Biden’s national security adviser, said on Tuesday that the principal U.S. objective at this year’s G20 would be increasing funding to the World Bank to help it counterbalance China’s Belt and Road initiative by lending money to smaller economies.

But Biden’s reluctance to consider returning to free-trade has been openly criticized by U.S. allies, including Australia. Canberra has said that the United States can’t beat Chinese influence without offering the world what it most wants: Access to the globe’s largest economy.

Under Biden, the Obama administration’s Trans-Pacific Partnership, which Tokyo repurposed into a free-trade pact without the United States, has been nixed in favor of the Indo-Pacific Economic Framework, which seeks to streamline, not remove, trade barriers.

That puts American officials on the backfoot at forums such as the G20, where foreign leaders show little interest in almost any other initiatives. 

“It’s hard to find anybody who’s enthused about the Indo-Pacific Economic Framework, because nobody really understands what’s in it or what it does,” said Gregory Poling, director of the Southeast Asia Program at the Center for Strategic and International Studies in Washington.

“What the region wants is free trade and market access,” he said, “and that’s the one thing the administration is not willing to give.” 

A blip

Zhao noted that in the absence of China and the United States showing leadership at the G20 summit this year, and a global system increasingly with “no hegemon,” little can be expected other than perfunctory statements on the Ukraine war and climate change. 

India, while intent on hosting an extravaganza, also does not yet have the economic heft to compete with China for influence in the Global South. 

Copy of ENG_CHN_G20_09062023.4.jpg
Rekha Devi, a 30-year-old farm worker, washes her face next to her temporary shelter on an under-construction overpass after her family evacuated the flooded banks of the Yamuna River in New Delhi, Aug. 9, 2023. [Altaf Qadri/AP]

Russian President Vladimir Putin’s absence from the summit, meanwhile, barely registers in headlines given the domestic issues he faces as the invasion of Ukraine drags on beyond a year and a half.

And for Xi, the hope is that the rippling economic effects of the pandemic only curtail its global influence for a little while longer.

“China’s economy has not recovered from COVID as the Chinese government expected and growth has slowed. Addressing this is now the Chinese government’s top priority,” said Susan Thornton, a senior fellow lecturer at Yale University’s Paul Tsai China Center who served as acting U.S. undersecretary of state for East Asia in 2017 and 2018.

But “China remains a major economic player, manufacturing powerhouse and number one global trader,” she said, “so it is early to say that China’s influence in this area will diminish.”

For the United States, New Delhi might provide the opportunity for some gloating in the face of a relatively stronger economic position, but it won’t hide from the world its refusals to play ball on free trade.

“Biden can tell a good story, particularly in a slowing Chinese economy,” said Poling, but “the lack of a proactive U.S. trade policy carries the headlines, no matter what other initiatives they launch.”

Radio Free Asia (RFA), a news service affiliated with BenarNews, produced this report. 


Add your comment by filling out the form below in plain text. Comments are approved by a moderator and can be edited in accordance with RFAs Terms of Use. Comments will not appear in real time. RFA is not responsible for the content of the postings. Please, be respectful of others' point of view and stick to the facts.